White shirt screen printed with what day is it in a rainbow of six ink colors

Why Do Bulk T-Shirt Quotes Vary So Much?

Three shops can quote the same 100 shirts and come back with three prices that are nowhere close. Here is what is actually inside the number.

You did everything right.

You sent the same logo to three print shops and asked each one for a price on 100 shirts.

One came back at $6 a shirt. Another came back at $11. The third came back somewhere in between and threw in a word you had never heard before.

So which one is right?

Honestly, they might all be right. They are just pricing different things.

A screen printing quote is built from a handful of ingredients: the shirt itself, how many you order, where the print goes, how many ink colors are in the design, and how fast you need it. Change any one of those and the price moves. Once you know what they are, comparing quotes gets a whole lot easier.

It Starts With the Shirt

The blank garment is the biggest variable in almost every quote. Two shirts can look about the same in a photo and cost very different amounts.

Let us tell you about our favorite.

It is the District DM130 Perfect Tri Tee. It is a super soft triblend, very similar to a shirt you have probably heard of: the Bella+Canvas triblend tee.

The difference is the fit.

Bella+Canvas has a fashion fit. It is cut close to the body. That is great if you spend a lot of time at the gym. But most of our customers are regular people. Teachers. Church members. Ball parents. Guys on a work crew. They do not necessarily want a shirt that clings to them.

The DM130 has a more traditional, boxier fit. Same softness, more forgiving.

The two shirts cost about the same. They are not at the very top of the price ladder for blank garments. Think upper middle class. Still a really good value for what usually ends up being the favorite shirt in your closet.

Two custom screen printed Okie Brand shirts, a charcoal tee with a tan Hunt Oklahoma design and a heather navy tee with a gold OKIE logo, on the shop's drying rack
Fresh shirts for our friends at The Okie Brand, one of our contract pricing customers.

Going up from there

When you get into the very on trend retail brands, like Shaka Wear or Comfort Colors, you are going to add anywhere from $3 to $5 per shirt to the cost of your project.

People love those shirts, and they are worth it for the right project. Just know that is where a big chunk of the price difference comes from.

Going down from there

If you are looking for something really affordable, we can do that too. Shirts like the Tultex 202 or the Port & Company PC43 come in at about half the price of the Bella+Canvas or the DM130.

Those shirts will not feel as soft. They are not the one people reach for first on a Saturday morning. But for a one day event, a giveaway, or a big group on a tight budget, they can be exactly the right call.

So when two quotes are far apart, the first question to ask is simple: what shirt is in each quote?

Every Kind of Garment Has Its Own Price Ladder

Prices go up or down depending on the type of garment you pick. Hoodies, long sleeves, crewneck sweatshirts, polos, and hats all start at different places.

And within each of those categories, there is a wide range of quality.

There are cheap hooded sweatshirts, and there are very, very expensive hooded sweatshirts, like the Independent Trading Co. IND4000, which is more of a retail level hoodie.

Our most popular hoodie lands right in the sweet spot. It is the Port & Company PC78. It is soft, it holds up, and it is cost effective. For most groups, it is the one we recommend.

Quantity Makes a Big Difference

Screen printing takes setup. Every design needs screens made, ink mixed, and a press dialed in before the first shirt gets printed. The more shirts that setup gets spread across, the less each shirt costs.

That is why most screen printing shops require you to buy at least 48 pieces.

At Rhodes Printing, our minimum is 15.

Our price breaks are at 15, 48, 100, 250, 500, and 1,000 pieces. Every time you cross one of those lines, your price per shirt drops.

If you get up to 2,500 pieces, you might qualify for contract pricing, like our customers the Tulsa Oilers and The Okie Brand.

Need fewer than 15? Heat transfer is the better fit for that. It is not our preferred decoration method, but it works pretty well when you are talking about extremely low quantities. (We break down the difference in screen printing vs. heat press.)

How Charlie’s Chicken Saves a Ton on Shirts

Here is a quick story about how contract pricing can really pay off.

Restaurants buy a lot of T-shirts. Employee turnover is pretty frequent, so they are always needing new shirts for new people.

Most restaurants order shirts a few at a time, whenever they run low.

Charlie’s Chicken was smarter than that. Instead of each restaurant ordering on its own, they worked together with all of their franchise locations, around 20 stores across the region, and placed one bulk order for every store at the same time.

That one order qualified them for contract pricing and saved them a ton of cash.

If your organization has several locations, departments, or teams that all buy shirts, it is worth asking whether you could do the same thing.

Where the Print Goes

Here is some good news: we do not charge any differently for a full chest print or a left chest print. It is the same amount of work for us, so it is the same price for you.

What will make your price go up a little is printing on the front and printing a separate image on the back. That is a second print, with its own screens and its own trip through the press.

Sleeve prints and tag prints on the inside of the collar also cost more. We consider both of those specialty prints. To do them, we have to shut down our presses and reset them with special platens made for sleeves and necks.

When you compare quotes, make sure every shop is pricing the same print locations.

How Many Ink Colors Are in Your Design

In screen printing, every ink color gets its own screen and its own pass on the press.

Our presses are built to print up to 6 colors of ink. A 6 color design will cost you more than a 1 color design, because there is more setup and more work on every shirt.

A 1 color design can look every bit as good, though. Here is one on a pink Bella+Canvas tee.

Pink Bella+Canvas T-shirt screen printed with LOVE GOD love people in one color of red ink, on the press platen
A 1 color print. One screen, one pass, and a clean, simple design.

And here is what a full 6 color print looks like.

White shirt screen printed with what day is it repeated five times in a rainbow of six ink colors with a black outline
A 6 color print. Six screens, six passes, and a lot more color.

If you are trying to hit a budget, ask us whether your design could work in fewer colors. Sometimes dropping one color saves real money without changing the look much at all.

When You Need It

Your timeline can affect your price too.

We pride ourselves on having the fastest production times in our industry, with a turnaround of 5 to 7 business days.

But we understand that sometimes you are really in a rush.

Maybe you have playoffs on Saturday, and you did not find out until Thursday that your team qualified. That happens a lot more often than you would think.

In a situation like that, we can bump you to the very front of our production schedule for an extra $150.

That might sound like a lot if you only need 15 shirts. But if you are buying a couple hundred shirts, it works out to less than $1 a shirt to have them in 2 days instead of 5 to 7.

How to Compare Quotes Fairly

Before you pick the lowest number, line your quotes up and check that they are pricing the same thing:

  • The same garment. Look for the brand and style number, not just “T-shirt.”
  • The same quantity. And notice which price break that quantity lands in.
  • The same print locations. Front only, front and back, sleeves, or tags.
  • The same number of ink colors in each location.
  • The same deadline. Is a rush charge hiding in one of them?
  • What is included. Artwork, proofs, setup, and shipping can all show up as extra charges somewhere else.

At Rhodes Printing, artwork and color separations are done in house at no charge, you get unlimited proof revisions until it looks right, and we offer free shipping anywhere in the US.

That way, the price you see is the price of your shirts.

Get a Real Number

The fastest way to know what your project costs is to ask. Tell us the garment you like, how many you need, where you want the print, and when you need it, and we will send you a quote you can actually compare.

Get your free quote from Rhodes Printing. And if you are the one organizing the order, catch up on part 1 of this series: The Organizer Carries All the Blame.

Like our printing tips? Make CrispyPrint one of your preferred sources on Google.